Researchers Call For Creation Of Standardized Meti Protocol For Talking To Extraterrestrials

Num7

Administrator
Staff
Messages
12,453
Since the first binary code sent from Puerto Rico in 1974, our messages to aliens have been increasingly complicated and cryptic, possibly so much that extraterrestrials won’t get what we’re saying.

A trio of astrophysicists from the US and France hope to change that by building an extraterrestrial messaging protocol, so any spacebound communiqué could be easily understood.

A METI protocol — messaging to extraterrestrial intelligence — would include several factors, including signal encoding, message length and message content, according to Dimitra Atri, an astronomer at the University of Kansas, and his colleagues. They suggest using two specific wavelengths for transmission: 1.42 GHz or 4.46 GHz, which are commonly observed in nature and relatively easy to capture, in case the ETs only have “modest technical capabilities.” They also recommend establishing a dedicated transmission beacon to conduct regular broadcasts.

They’re not the first to suggest a standardized communication approach; SETI astronomer Seth Shostak believes we should start looking for intelligent machines, for instance.

But Atri et. al’s most interesting critique is that to date, our messages have been overly anthropocentric. It’s a fair point: Some nine-limbed creature in the Gliese system probably wouldn’t understand the human nuances behind a message containing side-by-side images of George W. Bush and Barack Obama, meant to signify good and evil. Heck, they may not have the technical abilities required to process the data into an image at all.

“Given that we know very little about the nature of extraterrestrial civilizations, if they exist, we are likely to increase the probability of us successfully communicating to them if we use a message that the recipient is likely to understand,” the authors say.

To ensure this, they propose a worldwide test of the new METI protocol, figuring that if people across cultures can understand it, a basic ET might, too. International users could create and exchange messages through an interactive website, following the protocol to create a crowdsourced ideal message.

“An effective message to extraterrestrials should at least be understandable by humans, and releasing the protocol for testing will allow us to improve the protocol and develop potential messages,” the authors write.

Their paper, posted this week to the physics arXiv, has been accepted for publication in the journal Space Policy.

http://www.popsci.com/science/artic...d-standardized-communication-rules-study-says
 

Num7

Administrator
Staff
Messages
12,453
Seriously, there's absolutely no way to know how ETs communicate. I mean, radio, videos, sounds or images, all of these are encoded in some format or another. I don't ETs know what's a .WAV file or a JPG picture.

Other than that, there's no way to know if they use radio frequencies to communicate at all. Perhaps they don't even listen to those "noises" coming from outer space.

What do you think ? Does it make sense to sent out messages in hopes of reaching ETs ?
 

Pureone

New Member
Messages
5
I think the idea in "Contact" would be the best. Sending out mathematics would be the best. That was done on Voyager- Music. music is basically nothing but math and physics at it's base.
 

Num7

Administrator
Staff
Messages
12,453
I didn't think of that one, it sounds logical to say the least, but the music still needs to be deciphered. You must "store" this music in some kind of format like numbers, or data, etc. It must be translated so to speak in order to hear it, or to read it.

Even if the ETs get our message, should we expect an answer we're going to be able to understand ? How are they going to reply ? OK, if they land on Earth, we're going to understand, but what if they answer our message with their own technologies, with their own ways of communicating over long distances ? I wonder if we'd ever be able to understand anything out of this message.
 

Pureone

New Member
Messages
5
well, they put the music on golden records, included a player and pictographic instructions on how to play it.

I think it's not the message of the music quite so much, but more of telling them what we do understand about math and physics, where we are technologically. I realize that to us, digital music is technologically superior, but maybe to alien life forms, and considering the age of the universe, we are still technological infants in the big picture.

While that would be assuming that our constants are "universal" (heh), I still think that a mathematical signal of some sort would be the best to send out.

Well, they might respond in the same way as in "Contact". They might send a mathematical signal back. perhaps not to the same depth of message like in the movie, but enough to say "Hello". Any contact is better than none, Yes?
 

Pureone

New Member
Messages
5
Good point about possibly not receiving our/their message due to technological differences. I will say, if they can receive our messages, then they will know how to send back.
 

Top