Re: I Am Traveling Through Alternate Universes
regarding the fragility of memory, particularly my own ... I would generally be inclined to agree.
Although in this instance there was only around a year between reading the library version (new at the time) and me purchasing a copy.
I was quite keen on the book, which keeness should probably keep key elements in my mind over those 12-18 months. On my first reading I thought that certain plot twists were quite daring/unexpected and even mildly shocking.
So the lack of these twists in the purchased version was quite noticable.
As a crude example of a film which is resonant with many people and they have possibly seen it in the last 18 months, or remember it well.
Imagine you see Star Wars, Empire Strikes back, yet : Obi wan is happily alive, yet mentioned as a minor character and Luke embraces the darkside & his dad, Princess L is married to Luke and has a sister.
I think that is a rough parallel with my experience.
I am of couse aware that this book has a history which would tend to undermine anything associated with it. I was 20ish at the time though so I am hereby forgiven for liking it
>>>> edit <<<<<
after this thread re-kindled this ancient memory .. and since the intervening invention of the information superhighway, I stumbled across this explanatory gem
http://www.heinleinsociety.org/rah/works/n...vsstranger.html
there were actually two different versions !!!!
In 1991 they released his uncut version, the early version being deemed too dangerous (?)
>>> one more edit
reading the changes though they barely seem to scratch the surface of the changes I remember
Perhaps the Greg Egan permutation hypothesis is at work and the universe is protecting its own by retroactively producing an explanation before my reminiscences produce a ripple of inconvenience, in which case I fear for 'Unintentional's continued existance!
PKD of course was edited out, sadly, in 1985
regarding the fragility of memory, particularly my own ... I would generally be inclined to agree.
Although in this instance there was only around a year between reading the library version (new at the time) and me purchasing a copy.
I was quite keen on the book, which keeness should probably keep key elements in my mind over those 12-18 months. On my first reading I thought that certain plot twists were quite daring/unexpected and even mildly shocking.
So the lack of these twists in the purchased version was quite noticable.
As a crude example of a film which is resonant with many people and they have possibly seen it in the last 18 months, or remember it well.
Imagine you see Star Wars, Empire Strikes back, yet : Obi wan is happily alive, yet mentioned as a minor character and Luke embraces the darkside & his dad, Princess L is married to Luke and has a sister.
I think that is a rough parallel with my experience.
I am of couse aware that this book has a history which would tend to undermine anything associated with it. I was 20ish at the time though so I am hereby forgiven for liking it

>>>> edit <<<<<
after this thread re-kindled this ancient memory .. and since the intervening invention of the information superhighway, I stumbled across this explanatory gem
http://www.heinleinsociety.org/rah/works/n...vsstranger.html
there were actually two different versions !!!!
In 1991 they released his uncut version, the early version being deemed too dangerous (?)
>>> one more edit
reading the changes though they barely seem to scratch the surface of the changes I remember
Perhaps the Greg Egan permutation hypothesis is at work and the universe is protecting its own by retroactively producing an explanation before my reminiscences produce a ripple of inconvenience, in which case I fear for 'Unintentional's continued existance!
PKD of course was edited out, sadly, in 1985