I would let it renew on Feb 6. It would be very curious if the membership renewal did go through, but TF still doesn't show. We'd still have the mystery of what happened to him. However if it doesn't renew, I think it'd be safe to say he's not returning, sadly...I'm undecided.
If the payment passes, it suggests his credit card is still active and in use.
If it bounces back, it means his card has been canceled at some point between last summer, and now.
Renewal is on Feb 6.
I encourage you guys to let us know what you think we should do. Let it renew, see what happens? Or disable renewal?